Well, the disconcerting thing to me is if Clement goes to Indy, what happens to Pearce?
If the Pirates bench is Jaramillo, Crosby, Vazquez, Raynor, and either Moss or Young (with Church starting in RF, and G Jones at 1B), and the Indy OF is Van Every, Tabata, and B Jones, and Clement is playing 1B in Indy, where does Pearce even fit in?
He doesn't even fit in as an Indy utility guy. Because between Alvarez, A Diaz, Friday, Walker, and probaby Ford, the rest of the Indy infield is more than covered.
Additionally, to my knowledge, Brian Myrow will be back this year, to back-up the Indy corner OF spots, and 1B.
Of course, Pearce will play 1B at Indy, if Clement is on the Pirates. But if Clement makes the Pirates, then I can't see either Moss or Young with the ballclub on April 5th...with really no room for those guys in Indy, either. Even if one or both of them clears DFA waivers.
Moss, Young, Pearce. I fail to see how 2 of the 3 of them will still be in the organization, on April 5th.
A lot depends on whether the Pirates carry 11 or 12 pitchers. If they carry 11...Pearce makes the team.
12 pitchers...5 bench spots...JJ as backup catcher...2 middle infielders (Crosby and the winner of RV/Young)...2 OF/backup 1B (Church and one of Raynor/Moss/Pearce). This assumes Clement makes the team. If he doesn't...then Jones moves to 1B...Church becomes a starter...and 2 of Raynor/Moss/Pearce make the team...likely Raynor and Pearce.
11 pitchers...6 bench spots...JJ as backup catcher...2 middle infielders...Pearce at backup 1B (backing up either Jones or Clement)...Church and Raynor in the OF. If Clement doesn't make team...BJones or Walker might get the 25th spot.
Walker goes to Indy as a jack of all trades in any case. Moss and RV look for other employment. And come June...2 other guys may be on thin ice (winner of RV/Young will be one of them...and one OF).